The postulation by Alexander Herzen,
(1812-1870) became manifest during the last
set of elections in Nigeria.
The Russian reformist had written in one of
his famous essays “that the men who
proclaimed the Republic became the
assassins of freedom”.
Herzen submitted that those who claimed to
be pure revolutionists in Russia had in a way
abandoned the real struggle to secure true
liberty for all, and that though they had
broken the chains they inadvertently left the
prison walls standing, making them
assassins of freedom. The manipulations and
high level intrigues that characterised the just
concluded general elections in Nigeria can be
likened to a coup of some sort by those who
claim to be Nigeria’s most liberal politicians.
They proclaimed to the world that they
wanted a free, peaceful and credible election
but they connived with many forces to rob
Nigerians of the chance to freely elect their
leaders and deliberately arm twisted the
electoral umpire, Prof Attahiru Jega’s
Independent National Electoral Commission,
INEC, to short change Nigerians voters.
No doubt the elections have come and gone,
producing winners and losers but the ripples
generated have left many Nigerians with sour
taste because of the conspiracy of high-
ranking politicians, who worked hard to
subvert the will of Nigerians just to maintain
their electoral status-quo and keep smiling to
the bank.
Nonetheless, while the winners are in high
spirit, working round the clock to fix
themselves on the reins of power, the losers
continue to gnash their teeth, wondering
what might have hit them like a volcano. In a
way, the just-concluded polls, made history,
broke the jinx of incumbency and wrote a
new chapter in the Nigerian polity.
Surprisingly, although the changes introduced
by INEC to add credibility to the elections,
succeeded in certain ways to checkmate
mass figures of electoral victory usually
associated with Nigerian elections, it failed in
many ways to checkmate electoral fraud and
violence, effectively defeating the goals of the
innovations factored into the polls. It
appears that once majority of Nigerians
achieved the change they longed for in the
Presidential elections they overlooked many
flaws that marked the Presidential election
and actually floored the governorship
elections in some states.
Smart Card Readers and Permanent Voter
Cards: The good, the bad
The vision of those who contemplated the
use of the card readers and permanent voter
cards for the 2015 elections shows a clear
evidence of thoughtfulness and readiness to
part with the ugly past of Nigerian elections.
In the recent past, Nigerian leaders with an
eye for rigging, simply engaged in mass
thumb-printing according to the earmarked or
ascribed voter population in their respective
domains because there was no means of
ascertaining who reported for voting or not.
But with the introduction of the SCR the PVC,
it became clear to election riggers that it
would be difficult to continue with the
dubious business as usual.
The SCR simply put a ceiling to what
governors, lawmakers and their parties could
declare in the just-concluded polls. In fact, a
clear pattern simply emerged as the results
of the 2015 elections began to roll in: Out of
the 36 states and Abuja, none of them was
able to declare up to 50 percent score of the
votes when juxtaposed with the number of
the voter population claimed by the states
and the FCT, leaving political pundits to
wonder what might have happened to the
remaining ‘voters’.
In the recent past, Kano, and Lagos, which
emerged with the highest voter population
figures of about 5 million, would have
accordingly returned something close to that
figure without the use of the card readers,
which automatically pegged the number
which any state could declare at the end of
voting. But because of the application of the
technology, Kano which registered close to
five million voters and was actually issued
with over four million PVCs, could only return
two million votes while Lagos which had
about four million voters with PVCs was only
able to turn in about 1.4 million at the end of
the day. Thus, in a way the SMR worked to
some extent.
INEC’s dilemma and limitation in SMR usage
It is obvious that the success of the card
readers in the last election depended to a
large extent to the cooperation of key
political actors with the electoral umpire. It
was curious that in most PDP states,
particularly in the Southern part of the
country, where the governors had frontally
opposed the use of the technology on the
grounds that it would disenfranchise their
citizens, the card readers, accordingly
‘refused to work’ on election days. It ‘failed
woefully’ during the Presidential and National
Assembly polls in most PDP states until Jega
was compelled to authorise manual
accreditation when no such mass failure rate
was reported in the opposition controlled
states particularly in the northern part of the
country.
Two extreme cases in Daura, Katsina State
where Muhammadu Buhari reported for
voting and Otuoke in Bayelsa State where
President Goodluck Jonathan and Dame
Patience Jonathan were slated to vote, would
suffice. In Daura, the SCR seamlessly
accepted GMB’s and Aisha’s fingerprints
within seconds and they went home while in
the latter, the ‘sensitive machines’ stubbornly
refused to accept the fingerprints of the
president and Mama Peace, leaving them
standing on the sun as common citizens for
close to half an hour.
The scenario was simply frustrating,
confusing and provocative to the president’s
minders and those who watched the
disappointment on their faces. But most
disappointing was the INEC official, who
appeared as if he was handling a Rocket
Science apparatus that could easily explode
to consume him: he was helpless. As at
today, nobody knows what happened to the
machines in Otuoke and other PDP states.
Were they jammed by malevolent elements to
embarrass the first family or was it just an
innocent coincidence that nobody had
envisaged? A Correspondent of one of the
leading Tv stations in Nigeria, attached to the
Presidential Villa almost gave an inkling of
what was to happen during the accreditation
during a live transmission of the event, when
he warned his anchor man, not to disconnect
from the location but to ‘just stay on and
watch and see what is going to happen”. It
was a warning loaded with meanings, which
most people did not take seriously until the
‘failure’ occurred, to the chagrin of all.
Where is the SCR magic?
For all the benefits and promises which INEC
said the SCR would contribute to making
rigging impossible in the last election, the
cards simply could not significantly stall
mass rigging in most states where the
governors had already connived with
compromised security agents, INEC officials
and thugs to deliver a premeditated results
to prove that they were in charge or were
working for ’our son’.
Those governors simply made a ship wreck
of the card readers and still rolled out
impossible figures for INEC to announce at
the end of the day. They slapped Jega on the
face with their actions. After failing to
browbeat Jega to abandon the smart card,
the governors gladly sought and obtained the
support of security agents to back their well-
trained thugs and party agents to make a
mockery of the cards.
In most states, the government-backed thugs
merely waited for INEC officials to conclude
accreditation using the cards for them to
snatch both the result sheets, number of
accredited voters and the card readers and
move to their fortified locations to compute
the ‘result’ before handing over to the INEC
officials to announce with fanfare. In these
states, those masterminding the rigging were
fully aware that they could not win in a free
and fair contest, given the fact that some of
them insisted on certain candidates not
minding the feelings of the electorate.
One of the media coordinators for one
Southern governor said in a chat with this
reporter that they had to resort to hijacking
of sensitive election materials and writing the
results by themselves so as to avoid being
defeated in a free contest with the
opposition, which was very strong.
“We knew that without using our boys backed
by the security that we would lose to the
opposition governorship candidate,” the
source explained, adding “we have put the
opposition in a tight corner with our electoral
‘massive victory’; it is their duty to prove
whether we rigged or not but that is none of
our business.”
Eclipse of the security agencies or electoral
fraud accomplices?
For all the promises to help ensure free, fair
and credible polls in Nigeria, can the Nigerian
security agencies say boldly that they helped
in a significant way to advance credible
election or acted as a spoke in the wheel of
progress? The answer is yes and no.
Although the police high command and other
security agencies gave the world the
impression that their officers and men would
provide a level playing field for a credible and
peaceful election, the reverse was the case
when the interest of the two leading parties-
APC and PDP was factored in.
Most of the security men wanted to ‘deliver
victory’ at all cost for those who paid them
and by extension protect their jobs while a
handful insisted on doing the job
dispassionately and in the overall interest of
Nigeria. But the ‘big bosses’ would not allow
that to happen, hence the resort to ‘obey the
last order’ and comply with the ‘order from
above’, a situation which manifested in most
security agents aiding and abetting electoral
fraud and violence just to maintain the status
quo in many cases.
The elections cost Suleiman Abba his job as
Inspector General of Police. Some suspect
that Abba was being difficult to the ruling
party. He was accused of ‘not being sensitive
enough’ by posting a police officer suspected
to have sympathy for APC in Rivers State.
The PDP insisted on having a Hosea Karma
to conduct the election since he understands
the riverine state more than any other police
officer in Nigeria.
The attempt by Abba to ‘foist’ Ogunshakin on
the state to conduct the election alongside
three other AIGs and 2800 police men merely
infuriated the powers that be and quickened
his ouster from the force. While Ogunhakin
was forced to flee Port Harcourt for Calabar
in the early hours of the election day, the
other police officers and men, never dared to
set their feet on the Garden City throughout
the duration of the election.
At least, it will teach those who contested for
power that ‘what a man is afraid to do, a
courageous woman can accomplish that with
audacity and damn the consequences.
Security men were used to rig these
elections.
What worked and what didn’t work
Perhaps, the electoral umpire will be ready to
return to the drawing board to work out more
strategies to advance the Nigerian electoral
system. It should be able to demonstrate to
us that the card readers have the capacity to
transmit how many people were accredited in
all the polling units and indicate clearly
where cards readers were not used at or
deliberately manipulated for electoral fraud.
Without that, it may not make any sense
using it in future elections.
But the best way out is to launch Nigeria into
a full scale electronic voting to eliminate
intimidation, killings and snatching of
electoral materials. The earlier this is done,
the more likely the hope that the votes of
Nigerians will begin to count. Again, that is
the only way that those who spearheaded
our democracy will not turn round to oppose
reforms that will bring about sanity in the
system and become ‘’assassins of freedom”
like Herzen said .
No comments:
Post a Comment
Disclaimer: Opinions expressed
in comments are those of the
comment writers alone and
does not reflect or represent
the views of Special Reporters